Smart Locks—The Pros and Cons

The first question I get is, what is wrong with the old tried-and-true method—a key? Answer: Nothing. The decision to change to a smart lock technology should be because you want specific features of that type of lock and you have decided the potential negatives are outweighed by these new features. So, to make this decision, you first need to know your options.

  • Option 1—Traditional key lock. This is great for someone who doesn’t have an issue carrying around a key, has a specific set number of people who need access, the people who need access don’t change, and finally either doesn’t need to monitor who or when access activity happens OR fulfills that need via cameras.
  • Option 2—Mechanical combo lock. This is an often overlooked solution. Perfect for someone who doesn’t need tracking by the lock of who or when access is happening. Someone who doesn’t want all the potential complications associated with technology and, more importantly, solves the issue of needing to carry a key. These solutions are inexpensive, do NOT require a power source, and are straightforward to use and maintain. There are models good for both gate and traditional residential door security. Example Links: https://a.co/d/0ekJ5Owd, https://a.co/d/05HOx4V1.
  • Option 3—Electronic combo lock. This is where options start to occur, and you really need to evaluate the pros/cons of each specific model. Most can have more than one code and track usage by each code. This is particularly useful so your immediate family can have a simple code you always use and never change. Then, when you have someone like a house cleaner or landscaper, you can give them a different code that you change anytime you change services. Typically these locks require a Wi-Fi network and have a battery that will need periodic charging/replacing. Most also have the ability for real-time notifications via a smartphone. I also recommend this solution if you have latchkey kids. Do NOT give them the default home code. Give them a code that is unique to them. This way, if it is shared inappropriately and something happens, you know specifically what code was used, can have that discussion about security with your child (i.e., do not share their home code with your “friends”), and should change it regularly (recommend once a year). Example Links: https://a.co/d/04rKTwhd, https://a.co/d/01WIvesE, https://a.co/d/0cDaXECL. NOTE: I always recommend anything that requires power should always be designed with a physical key backup that is hidden onsite. Some smart lock designs do NOT have this feature. Most of them do have a low battery indicator, but humans tend to ignore messages. You would rather not be locked out of your home with no other alternatives for access other than breaking in.

Home/Gate Locks — Smart or Not?

When consider installing or replacing existing locks on doors or gates, you should consider some features for smart or very not smart solutions that don’t require a key! Smart locks have one universal issue…power. Most of them have batteries that are very long-lasting, but at some point, you will probably be trying to enter your home, and it will not work because the battery is too low. At a minimum, you should not consider any smart lock that doesn’t have a key bypass override. Proactively replacing/charging batteries on a set cycle is also a best practice. Most smart locks include a phone app that allows you to set up more than one code, so you know who is coming and going. This is particularly good if you want to give a “worker” something temporary and not the easy to remember code you use for yourself.

Some options are:

Some Patio Door Options:

Some Gate Options:

Now, if you want to go “old school” but hate having to carry keys, you should consider a keyless mechanical lock. No battery issues here. No connectivity issues. Complete privacy.

Give me a call/text/email if you want some help finding the right solution.